Are e-collars inhumane?

Most of my clients are completely new to using certain training tools, like prong collars and e-collars. Many clients feel nervous about using these tools, because they are unfamiliar with how to use the tools and they are understandably concerned about physically or emotionally hurting their dog. There is a lot of fear-mongering around the use of different training tools, and horror stories about dogs being abused or coming out of training programs traumatized sadly do exist.

My programs are designed specifically to create reliability while supporting the unique spirit of each dog. This is why my programs are results based and longer than other companies'--I refuse to rush dogs through speedy, compulsion-based training programs, which are often really stressful for the dog and may ultimately break the dogs' spirit. My goal is to use the least amount of force required for owners to have safe, secure dogs. Some trainers and animal rights advocates try and argue that forcing dogs to do anything is abuse. I strongly disagree with this. Dogs, like people, need clarity in their lives to thrive. Clarity requires an understanding of what is acceptable behavior and what is unacceptable behavior. Unpleasant consequences for unacceptable behavior is necessary for people and dogs to learn.

It is true that both people and dogs don't "enjoy" receiving consequences for unacceptable behavior. A common analogy I give to families is the response they may get from their child when they've instructed their child to go clean their room. Of course, most children are not going to happily skip off to their room to clean and make their bed--they would rather play instead! The annoyance or sadness a child might express when they are forced to stop playing and go clean their room is not because what is being asked of them is unfair or abusive. Parents try to teach their children housekeeping skills to cultivate a sense of responsibility in their child, and so that someday their child may be able to take care of themselves and maintain a hygienic and peaceful living space. As adults, we all do things that we don't want to do because we know they are best for us, and because we have practice prioritizing safety and long-term interests over short-term satisfaction.

This same logic applies in our relationship with our dogs--using training tools gives dogs clarity by way of teaching dogs what is acceptable and unacceptable behavior, helps dogs develop impulse control, and improves the relationships that owners have with their dogs. Dogs, like children, don't inherently know how to practice self-control and safety. Reward-based-only training cannot succeed with the majority of dogs out there who will refuse the highest value treat in order to do something else, like greet another dog or person, chase an animal, follow a scent, etc. Because we can't reason with our dogs verbally into listening, nor "ground" our dogs for misbehavior, there is simply no way to teach and compel our dogs to do things they don't want to do unless we use force by way of training tools like the prong collar and e-collar. Using training tools and creating clarity for our dogs not only keeps our dogs safe and more mentally stable, it also improves our relationship with them. Our dogs learn to trust us as reliable, fair and clear partners and leaders who keep them safe. Using rewards and providing safe outlets for our dogs to rehearse their genetic desires, in conjunction with the use of training tools, brings joy and fulfillment to our dog's life and our partnership with them. This is why I heavily support the use of rewards in the way that best supports each dog, and I try to teach owners how to give their dogs safe outlets for their dogs' genetic predisposition--this might look like letting dogs use their nose to scent as a reward, rather than giving them food, and teaching owners how to play fetch or tug with their dog, etc. 

I never judge current or potential clients for their comfort or thoughts about training tools, and I will never force a client to use training tools they aren't comfortable with. My goal is to educate and give clients and potential clients clear expectations around what results are possible with different training methods, and to help my clients achieve their training  goals with their dog. 

If you have any more questions about my methods or different training tools, feel free to reach out!

- Hillary